The SEC’s Argument Against XRP’s Value
The XRP community is questioning the US Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) argument that XRP has no value, suggesting that the regulator is attempting to tarnish the token’s reputation. Pro-XRP legal expert Bill Morgan believes that the SEC either misunderstands XRP or intentionally wants to hinder Ripple’s progress as a decentralized payment system.
Key Points:
– The SEC claimed in its memorandum of law that XRP has no intrinsic value, countering Ripple’s motion for summary judgment.
– Ripple argued that investors purchased XRP as a payment rather than an investment, but the SEC argued that assets like gold, which have intrinsic value, can still be sold as investment contracts.
– The SEC further contends that whether an asset has intrinsic value or not, its sales can be classified as investment contracts.
– Judge Torres classified digital assets with commodities, which seemed to upset the SEC, leading them to emphasize once again that XRP has no intrinsic value.
Relevance to the Crypto Community
Morgan suggests that the SEC’s claim that XRP has no intrinsic value is a tactic to encourage token issuers to find utility for their tokens. This could satisfy the third prong of the Howey test, implying that investors rely on the issuers’ efforts to increase the token’s value.
Key Points:
– The SEC aims to differentiate XRP from commodities by emphasizing that XRP has no intrinsic value upon creation.
– If this argument holds, it could be applied to all crypto tokens.
– The SEC’s intention may be to portray crypto tokens as an asset class with no intrinsic value, potentially deterring potential buyers.
Hot Take
The SEC’s argument that XRP has no value raises concerns about the regulator’s understanding of cryptocurrencies and their potential. By dismissing the intrinsic value of XRP and potentially other crypto tokens, the SEC may be hindering innovation and discouraging investment in the crypto market. It is crucial for the crypto community to push for regulatory clarity and understanding to foster growth and development in the industry.
By
By
By
By
By