The Uncertainty of Cryptocurrency Classification in the U.S.
In the United States, there is still uncertainty surrounding the legal classification of cryptocurrencies. This issue is currently being explored in multiple court cases. A major debate revolves around whether cryptocurrencies should be considered securities, either on their own or during initial coin offerings (ICOs). The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) takes the position that nearly all cryptocurrencies are securities, with bitcoin being the only known exception.
If cryptocurrencies are classified as securities, it would have significant implications for their regulation. They would need to be registered with the SEC, and crypto exchanges would also need to be SEC-regulated and trade only regulated cryptocurrencies. However, due to their decentralized nature, it is challenging to regulate many of the largest cryptocurrencies effectively, effectively banning them in the U.S. under current SEC regulations.
What Defines a Security?
According to U.S. law, securities are “investment contracts” where investors expect profits primarily from the efforts of a promoter or a third party. This profit realization can occur through the sale of the security or through dividends or interest payments. The SEC often relies on the Howey Test, derived from a 1946 U.S. Supreme Court case, to determine if transactions are investment contracts and subject to securities laws.
The Howey Test defines sales of securities as “investment contracts” when there is an investment of money in a common enterprise with a reasonable expectation of profits derived from the efforts of others. This test has played a fundamental role in enforcement cases involving cryptocurrencies, such as Ripple’s XRP token and Dapper Labs’ NBA Top Shot NFTs.
Implications of Being Classified as a Security
Classifying a cryptocurrency as a security has significant implications for both issuers and investors. If a cryptocurrency is deemed a security under the Howey Test, the issuer and exchanges must obtain licenses from securities regulators, which can be a challenging and time-consuming process. The SEC has already applied the Howey Test in lawsuits against Ripple, Coinbase, and Binance.
While bitcoin has been excluded from the Howey Test definition of a security, other cryptocurrencies may still be subject to federal securities laws. The SEC Chair Gary Gensler has emphasized that most cryptocurrencies and crypto firms are subject to such regulations.
Howey Test and Initial Coin Offerings
The application of the Howey Test extends to initial coin offerings (ICOs) as well. Former SEC Chair Jay Clayton stated that tokens used in ICOs are securities. The classification of ICOs under the Howey Test significantly impacts their legal and regulatory treatment. If an ICO is conducted in a way where investors expect profits primarily from the efforts of the project’s team or a third party, the tokens sold in the ICO could be considered securities.
The SEC’s “Framework for the Investment Contract Analysis of Digital Assets” highlighted factors like speculation and lack of utility in classifying certain tokens as securities during the ICO boom. Kik’s Kin token serves as an example of a failed ICO where the SEC sued Kik for offering securities based on claims of substantial profits.
The ongoing debate surrounding the application of the Howey Test to ICOs and token classification highlights the complexity and evolving nature of cryptocurrency regulation.
Hot Take: The Need for Clarity in Cryptocurrency Regulation
The uncertainty surrounding cryptocurrency classification as securities in the U.S. creates challenges for both industry participants and regulators. Without clear guidelines, companies face difficulties navigating compliance requirements, while investors may be exposed to potential risks without adequate protections.
Regulatory clarity is crucial for fostering innovation and attracting investment in the cryptocurrency space. Establishing a comprehensive framework that considers the unique characteristics of cryptocurrencies while addressing investor protection concerns is necessary for the sustainable growth of this emerging industry.
By
By
By
By
By