Gamers and Voice Actors Protest AI Voices in Video Games
A controversy has erupted in the gaming community over the use of AI voices in the upcoming first-person shooter game, The Finals. Andreas Almström, audio director of Embark Studios, the creator of The Finals, revealed in a podcast that they used AI to generate most of the voices in the game. While Almström praised the power and flexibility of AI text-to-speech technology, many voice actors and gamers have expressed their displeasure with this approach.
Controversial Use of AI in Gaming
The use of AI in gaming has become more prevalent, allowing developers to automate certain tasks and focus on other critical aspects of game development. However, this strategy has faced backlash. In June, Steam rejected a developer’s game for using AI-generated content due to potential copyright infringement. Similarly, Myst developer Cyan Worlds faced criticism for not crediting voice actors in their new release that utilized AI.
Voice Actors Speak Out Against AI Voices
The comments made by Almström received swift condemnation from voice actors who took to Twitter to express their concerns. Paxson Helgesen, a senior sound designer at Bungie and voice actor, encouraged developers to reconsider the use of AI voices as mere assets in game development. Other voice actors like Ben Prendergast voiced their confidence in the value of human voices and storytelling.
The Debate Continues
The controversy surrounding the use of AI voices in video games highlights an ongoing debate within the gaming community. Some argue that AI is a valuable tool that allows for efficiency and innovation, while others believe it undermines the craft and artistry of voice acting. Ultimately, the decision to use AI voices or prioritize human performances remains a complex ethical and artistic choice for game developers.
Hot Take: Balancing Efficiency and Artistry in Gaming
The use of AI voices in video games has sparked a heated discussion among gamers and voice actors. While AI technology offers advantages such as flexibility and responsiveness, many argue that it diminishes the unique contributions of human voice actors. Striking a balance between efficiency and artistry is crucial for game developers as they navigate the evolving landscape of AI in gaming.
By
By
By
By