Speculating on the Potential Fee for BlackRock’s Bitcoin ETF
As the decision date for the Bitcoin spot ETF nears, the crypto and broader financial community is speculating about the potential fee BlackRock might charge. Following a post on Twitter from Bloomberg’s senior analyst Eric Balchunas, the investor community is digging for “the biggest unknowns.” Balchunas has guessed a fee of 0.47%, inviting others to share their predictions.
Bitcoin ETFs intend to make revenue
Barry Ritholtz, CIO of Ritholtz Wealth Management, suggested that a fee of 0.35% would be competitive for BlackRock. He considered Vanguard’s absence in this fee range. That said, he noted that if BlackRock were to set a fee as low as 0.25%, it would dominate the space. Balchunas responded that BlackRock could potentially charge between 0.40% and 0.60% due to their intent to generate significant revenue. On a lighter note, a user named Maximilian humorously speculated a fee of 0.42069%, to which Balchunas replied that BlackRock typically doesn’t engage in humor with their fee structures.
The broader context includes competition from other firms. Fidelity’s S-1 filing revealed a competitive fee structure at 0.39%, previously the lowest until Invesco Galaxy’s entry. Invesco Galaxy has taken an aggressive approach by waiving fees for the first six months and for the first $5 billion in assets.
BlackRock: Threat to democracy?
The Financial Times highlights that BlackRock’s dominance in the US exchange-traded fund market is diminishing. Citing data from Morningstar Direct, the paper recently noted that Vanguard and smaller players in the space are tough competition for BlackRock. As of November, BlackRock’s iShares reportedly managed about 32% of the US ETF market, down from 33.7% in late 2022 and a significant drop from 39% at the end of 2018.
While BlackRock’s iShares aims to cater to a broad market, Vanguard focuses on stocks and bonds, leveraging its reputation for low-cost, broad-based strategies, as noted by Bryan Armour, Morningstar’s director of passive research. This strategic difference could be a key factor in the evolving ETF market, which could see Bitcoin become one of its players.
Meanwhile, Democratic Party member Bernie Sanders highlighted the immense influence of BlackRock and a few other powerful firms as a potential risk to democracy. In a post on Twitter, the US politician emphasized that BlackRock, along with Vanguard and State Street, manage a staggering $20.7 trillion in assets. Additionally, he noted their substantial shareholdings, being major investors in 95% of the companies that make up the S&P 500 index.
Hot Take: Balancing Profit and Competition
The speculation around BlackRock’s potential fee for its Bitcoin ETF highlights the importance of finding a balance between generating revenue and staying competitive in the evolving ETF market. While some suggest lower fees to dominate the space, others argue for higher fees to maximize profits. Additionally, BlackRock faces competition from firms like Vanguard and Invesco Galaxy who offer competitive fee structures or waive fees temporarily. The diminishing dominance of BlackRock in the US ETF market adds another layer of complexity to this situation. As the decision date approaches, it will be interesting to see how BlackRock positions itself in this highly competitive landscape.
By
By
By
By
By