Is Crypto Legitimacy as an Asset Class Still in Question Despite Spot Bitcoin ETFs Approval by U.S. SEC and TradFi Giants, According to FT’s Jemima Kelly?

Bitcoin Market Recovery and ETF Approval

Bitcoin’s recent market recovery and the SEC’s approval of spot Bitcoin ETFs indicate substantial development in the cryptocurrency industry. The market valuation has doubled over the past twelve months, marking a significant recovery since late 2022. The approval of 11 spot Bitcoin ETFs mirrors a critical shift in promoting Bitcoin as a legitimate asset class.

Skepticism Despite Developments

Rather than embracing these developments, columnist Jemima Kelly argues that Bitcoin’s legitimacy remains questionable. Despite approval from industry figures, including the SEC, Kelly believes that Bitcoin’s status as a legitimate asset class still lacks concrete evidence.

SEC’s Stance and Gensler’s Remarks

The SEC’s approval does not necessarily signify a broader acceptance of Bitcoin and crypto. SEC Chair Gary Gensler has noted that Bitcoin remains a speculative and volatile asset used for illicit activities.

Comparison with Other ETFs

Comparing spot Bitcoin ETFs to other unconventional SEC-approved ETFs illustrates the diverse and sometimes controversial nature of ETF offerings—it does not significantly endorse Bitcoin’s legitimacy.

Vanguard’s Refusal of Crypto-Related Products

Vanguard has made it clear that they won’t consider or offer cryptocurrency-related products like Bitcoin ETFs in their portfolio due to their stringent product launch process and the inherent speculative nature of Bitcoin.

Extreme Volatility and Long-Term Investing

Vanguard views Bitcoin’s price volatility as discouraging long-term investing and saving. Their history of avoiding fleeting investment trends confirms their commitment to their long-term investing philosophy.

JPMorgan CEO’s Verdict on Cryptocurrencies

JPMorgan CEO Jamie Dimon recognizes the value of blockchain technology while remaining critical of cryptocurrencies. He categorizes them into two groups—speculative assets and those with practical applications. His skepticism regarding Bitcoin is rooted in its speculative nature and potential association with illicit activities.

Hot Take

Crypto market fluctuations and Bitcoin ETFs reflect an ongoing struggle for legitimacy despite significant industry advancements. The critical scrutiny—like that from Jemima Kelly and the strategic stance taken by entities like Vanguard—underscores the complex nature of the cryptocurrency industry.