The U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) Retracts “Emergency” Survey on Bitcoin Mining Energy Use
A recently launched “emergency” survey aimed at collecting data on the energy consumption of U.S. Bitcoin mining companies has been retracted due to legal pressure from the industry. The Texas Blockchain Council and Riot Platforms, a leading Bitcoin mining firm, sought a temporary restraining order against the EIA, citing “administrative overreach” in implementing the survey. On February 26, the EIA confirmed that it would discontinue its plans for the emergency survey.
Background of the Survey
The EIA’s survey was announced in late January and would have required U.S. mining firms to provide detailed information about their electricity consumption. Failure to comply could have resulted in criminal fines. The survey aimed to collect data on various aspects of mining operations, including the number and location of facilities, sources of power, and involvement with proof-of-work or proof-of-stake blockchains.
Legal Pressure and Retraction
The Texas Blockchain Council and Riot Platforms filed a lawsuit against the EIA, arguing that the survey was unreasonable and posed a threat to the cryptocurrency mining industry. They claimed that the emergency justification provided by the EIA was not valid and could cause irreparable harm to the industry. In response to the legal pressure, the EIA decided to discontinue its plans for the emergency survey.
Implications for Future Requests
The Texas Blockchain Council emphasized that before considering similar requests in the future, the EIA will be required to follow standard notice and comment processes. This implies that any future surveys or data collection initiatives targeting Bitcoin mining companies will need to go through regular procedures and allow for public input.
Hot Take: Industry Victory Against EIA’s Emergency Survey
The retraction of the EIA’s emergency survey on Bitcoin mining energy use is seen as a significant victory for the cryptocurrency mining industry. The legal pressure applied by the Texas Blockchain Council and Riot Platforms successfully halted the implementation of the survey, which was deemed unreasonable and potentially harmful to the industry.
Reasons for Opposition
The Chamber of Digital Commerce, a prominent industry organization, expressed support for data sharing but criticized the EIA’s survey and emergency justification. They argued that the survey posed a threat to the cryptocurrency mining industry without reasonable cause. The industry has previously faced scrutiny regarding its energy consumption, but studies have shown that estimates of power consumption were overstated and that sustainable energy sources are widely used in mining operations.
Impact on Future Data Collection
The retraction of the survey sets a precedent for future data collection initiatives targeting Bitcoin mining companies. It highlights the importance of following standard procedures and allowing for public input before implementing such surveys. This victory for the industry could shape how regulatory agencies approach data collection in the future.
By
By
By