Should You Long Bitcoin and Short MicroStrategy Shares?
Today, Kerrisdale Capital, a hedge fund, unveiled a nuanced investment thesis: advocating for a long position on Bitcoin while simultaneously recommending a short position on MicroStrategy shares. This strategy is based on the assessment that MicroStrategy, touted as a de facto Bitcoin investment vehicle, is currently trading at a significantly inflated premium compared to the actual value of Bitcoin.
Analysis of Long Bitcoin, Short MSTR Strategy
Kerrisdale Capital’s analysis points out that while MicroStrategy’s stock has surged due to the recent Bitcoin price increase, there seems to be an exaggeration in the valuation. This discrepancy is evident as MicroStrategy’s stock price implies a Bitcoin value of over $177k, which is two and a half times the current spot price of Bitcoin.
- The hedge fund’s study dismantles various arguments supporting the premium on MicroStrategy’s shares, asserting that none of the commonly cited reasons justify paying such a substantial premium for the company’s stock compared to direct exposure to Bitcoin.
- Under the leadership of CEO Michael Saylor, MicroStrategy has actively pursued the accumulation of Bitcoin, incorporating it as a key component of its investment strategy. The company has significantly increased its Bitcoin holdings from August 2020 to 2023, now surpassing 214,000 BTC.
Evaluation of MicroStrategy’s Business Model
Kerrisdale Capital’s valuation approach assesses both MicroStrategy’s enterprise software business and its Bitcoin reserves. The findings indicate that while the software business remains operational, it no longer contributes a significant value to the overall enterprise, underlining the overwhelming impact of Bitcoin on the company’s valuation.
Premium Over Net Asset Value Analysis
An essential aspect of Kerrisdale’s critique revolves around the inflated premium over Net Asset Value (NAV) attributed to MicroStrategy’s shares. The report highlights that at 2.6 times, MicroStrategy’s equity premium is exceptionally high, suggesting an unsustainable market position in comparison to historical data.
- Kerrisdale argues that a correction towards a more historically consistent premium would indicate a substantial downside for MicroStrategy’s stock concerning Bitcoin’s performance.
- The report explores the potential implications of MicroStrategy’s financial strategy, including its reliance on leverage and the dilution effects of its financing mechanisms.
Community Reactions and Market Status
Following the release of the report, there were mixed reactions within the crypto community. Some critics expressed skepticism, while others acknowledged the rationale behind the long Bitcoin, short MicroStrategy shares recommendation.
- At the time of reporting, Bitcoin was trading at $71,519.
Hot Take: Kerrisdale’s Provocative Investment Thesis
As a savvy crypto investor, the proposal to long Bitcoin while shorting MicroStrategy shares presents an intriguing opportunity to capitalize on market discrepancies. While the strategy may spark debate, it underscores the importance of critical analysis and prudent decision-making in navigating the dynamic crypto landscape.
By
By
By