Crypto IP Rights: Understanding the Controversy 🎨
When NFTs burst onto the scene as a new asset class, speculation was rampant. Now, NFT projects are vying to establish more serious and sustainable futures, often focusing on intellectual property (IP) rights. But what does IP really mean in this context? Can NFT projects truly grant IP rights to their holders? These questions came to the forefront recently when Yuga Labs, the company behind Bored Ape Yacht Club, announced plans to grant exclusive commercial rights to Moonbirds NFT holders.
The Moonbirds Controversy Unpacked 🦉
Yuga Labs faced a hurdle with their plan as the original creators of Moonbirds had filed the collection under Creative Commons 0 (CC0), effectively releasing the artwork into the public domain. Despite this, Yuga Labs announced that ownership of Moonbirds would now be required to continue utilizing its artwork.
- Yuga Labs announced plans to grant commercial rights to Moonbirds NFT holders
- Original creators had released the Moonbirds collection into the public domain
- Users questioned the legality of Yuga Labs’ announcement
Following backlash from the community, Yuga Labs adjusted their stance. They specified that commercial rights would only apply to new, 3D versions of Moonbirds artwork, exclusive to current NFT holders. This move mirrors the approach taken with Bored Ape Yacht Club, where holders can create and sell various ventures under the brand.
Copyright vs. Trademark in NFTs 🖌️
Brian Frye, a law professor specializing in NFTs, explains the distinction between copyright and trademark in the context of NFT commercial rights. While Yuga claims commercial rights stem from individual NFT copyrights, Frye argues that commercial ventures under a brand like Bored Ape utilize trademark law, not individual copyright.
- Yuga focuses on individual NFT copyright for commercial rights
- NFT commercial ventures often leverage brand trademarks, not copyrights
- Legal scholars believe NFT commercial rights are complex within the crypto space
Yuga may have the authority to regulate the commercial use of Moonbirds but enforcing individualized, copyright-based commercial rights controlled by NFT holders may not be feasible. The original Moonbirds under CC0 remain in the public domain, but trademark protection still applies.
Hot Take: The Future of NFT Commercial Rights 💡
The Moonbirds controversy sheds light on the evolving landscape of IP rights in the NFT space. While the allure of owning IP rights is strong, the legal clarity around the issue remains murky. NFT brands must navigate the delicate balance between commercial viability and community goodwill to thrive in the long run.
Sources: Moonbirds Announcement
By
By
By
By