Italian Government Plans Major Changes to Crypto Taxation 💸
This year, Italy’s Deputy Minister of Economy, Maurizio Leo, announced a significant proposal to alter the nation’s approach to cryptocurrency taxation. The government aims to raise the tax rate on capital gains derived from the sale of Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies from 26% to 42%. This increase places Italy among the countries with the highest tax rates in Europe.
Details of the Proposed Tax Increase 🚨
In a recent press conference, Deputy Minister Leo, alongside Minister of Economy Giancarlo Giorgetti, outlined key aspects of this new economic plan. Their focus on revising cryptocurrency taxes came as part of broader economic policy discussions for 2025.
During the announcement, Leo reiterated the proposal to elevate the withholding tax on crypto capital gains to 42%. Currently, Italy applies a tax rate of 26%, which, while relatively average in comparison to other European nations, may soon change.
To provide context, Germany’s capital gains tax stands at 26.4%, while Spain imposes a 28% rate. By contrast, if the proposed increase is implemented, Italy would have the highest rate in Europe, identical to that of Denmark at 42%.
Looking at other countries, France levies a 34% tax, and the UK has a rate of 20%. Interestingly, Switzerland boasts no capital gains tax at all, maintaining a rate of 0%. Beyond Denmark, only Norway (37.8%) comes close, with France and Finland tied at 34%.
Likelihood of Tax Increase Approval 📊
The likelihood of this tax hike being approved by Parliament appears high according to Deputy Minister Leo’s statements. Still, it’s important to note that the government has yet to submit the final draft of this proposal to Parliament. There remains a chance that the suggested increase could be moderated.
As a strategic move, the government may choose to align the Italian rate with Spain’s 28% or potentially France’s 34%. The current consensus suggests it’s improbable that the rate for crypto capital gains will remain unchanged.
In response, members of the Italian cryptocurrency community are voicing concerns through a petition on Change.org. While the prospects for the petition’s success seem minimal, community members feel compelled to advocate for their interests.
Challenges Posed by a 42% Tax Rate 🚧
Italy already faces considerable tax burdens, and a further increase may exacerbate this issue. According to the OECD, Italy’s tax revenue as a percentage of GDP stands at 42.6%. Although not as high as France (47.4%), this figure ranks Italy as the sixth highest in the EU.
In comparison, tax revenue in Switzerland is just 27.4%, while Germany’s is 41.7%, and Greece’s is slightly lower at 41.9%. The current government had previously committed to not raising taxes in the 2025 budget, but given the uncertain credibility of Italian politicians, abrupt tax policy changes are not uncommon.
Raising taxes in a country with already high rates may drive individuals to seek more favorable conditions elsewhere, such as Switzerland, which shares a border with Italy and offers a canton where Italian is spoken.
Such initiatives may particularly affect high-net-worth individuals, leading to an economic drain rather than growth. Professor Ferdinando Ametrano, a specialist in Bitcoin and blockchain at the University of Milano-Bicocca, labeled the proposed 42% tax as “fiscally discriminatory and potentially unconstitutional.” He warned that such a move could lead to capital flight and market distortions in Italy.
Discrepancies in Tax Treatment of Financial Products 🏦
One of the most contentious aspects of this proposal is that it targets Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies while ignoring exchange-traded products such as ETPs, ETFs, and ETCs. Ametrano highlighted this disparity, noting that this discrepancy creates an unequal playing field where those investing in Bitcoin through derivative products would face a lower capital gains tax of 26%.
This situation has raised concerns among many in the cryptocurrency sector. Experts hope that the government will initiate discussions with crypto industry operators to explore alternative solutions for enhancing tax revenue without fostering unfair inequalities.
However, if the proposal were to gain approval, it could severely impact Italy’s burgeoning crypto sector precisely when the country needs to innovate and stimulate economic activity.
In summary, while attempts to enhance state revenue might be well-intentioned, the potential consequences of implementing drastic tax increases could have unintended effects detrimental to the country’s economy and its crypto community.
By
By
