Coinbase VS SEC: First Round of Oral Arguments Concludes
The initial round of oral arguments in the legal battle between Coinbase and U.S. regulators has ended without any immediate rulings. However, Judge Katherine Polk Failla, who presided over the case, expressed her admiration for Coinbase’s understanding of the issues and technologies involved.
Coinbase’s Defense on Staking
Judge Failla commended the “DeFi people” for their amicus brief filed on behalf of Coinbase, which provided a better explanation of blockchain staking than the SEC had previously offered. The DeFi education fund argued that Coinbase’s staking service should not be considered an unregistered security. They stated that Coinbase’s role in staking is purely administrative and comparable to an IT service provider, thus not meeting the requirements of the Howey Test.
Questioning the Validity of Howey Test
Judge Failla raised questions about the relevance of the Howey Test, citing arguments from Senator Cynthia Lummis, who supports cryptocurrency. She asked why Lummis should be considered wrong, stating that after 90 years of securities laws, there is something new in the market.
During the hearing, Coinbase argued that the SEC’s interpretation of the Howey Test is too broad and that none of the 12 tokens on their platform labeled as securities by the agency actually meet that definition.
Waiting for a Decision
It is expected that Judge Failla will take approximately 2 to 6 weeks to decide whether to dismiss the case or proceed with further legal proceedings, similar to the SEC’s lawsuit against Ripple Labs.
Hot Take: Evaluating Coinbase’s Legal Battle Against SEC
The first round of oral arguments in the Coinbase vs. SEC case has concluded, with no immediate rulings. However, the judge seemed impressed with Coinbase’s understanding of the issues at hand. The case revolves around whether Coinbase’s staking service should be considered an unregistered security. Coinbase argued that the SEC’s interpretation of the Howey Test is outdated and overbroad. The judge also questioned the validity of the Howey Test, citing arguments from a supportive senator. It remains to be seen how the judge will rule on this case, but it could have significant implications for the crypto industry as a whole.
By
By
By
