SEC’s Appeal Motion Dismissed by Judge in Ripple Lawsuit
The United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has suffered a setback in its legal battle against Ripple Labs as District Court Judge Analisa Torres has dismissed the SEC’s interlocutory appeal motion. The judge cited the regulator’s failure to convincingly demonstrate “controlling questions of law” and “substantial grounds for differences of opinion.” While this is a setback for the SEC, it does not signify the end of the litigation. The trial has been scheduled for April 23, 2024, to further address the outstanding issues of the case.
Impact of Ruling on SEC and Ripple
Jeremy Hogan, a respected lawyer in the XRP community, highlighted the significance of the recent ruling. He stated that the SEC’s motion for interlocutory appeal had been denied, meaning that the case would either go to trial in April or be dismissed. Hogan also emphasized that this order allowed the judge to clarify parts of her ruling, making an appeal more challenging for the SEC to win. Bill Morgan expressed satisfaction with the decision and confirmed that the trial would proceed on April 23, 2024.
Timeline for Ripple vs. SEC Litigation
Attorney Fred Rispoli offered a speculative roadmap for the litigation process. He noted that after the trial in April 2024, there would be post-trial motions from both parties, which could take a few months to complete. Appellate briefing to the 2nd Circuit would likely be finished around February 2025, and if the case proceeds to this level, a ruling can be expected around February 2026. However, Rispoli also mentioned that a Supreme Court decision would take even longer if review is accepted.
Broader Ramifications of the Court Decision
Scott Chamberlain, a former lawyer and co-founder of Evernode XRPL, believes that the recent court decision has significant implications. He stated that while the SEC can still appeal, it will face difficulties due to the factual record established during the trial. Chamberlain also mentioned that the Supreme Court is now less likely to be involved in the case, making it harder for the SEC to win.
Jury Trial Date Set for Ripple Labs and Executives
In August, Judge Torres ordered a jury trial involving Ripple Labs, CEO Brad Garlinghouse, and co-founder Chris Larsen. Originally projected between April 1 and June 30, 2024, the trial date has been adjusted to April 23, 2024, due to scheduling conflicts. The SEC and the defendants have indicated their availability or unavailability during specific dates in April and May.
Pivotal Trial Deadlines Established
The parties involved must submit any motions by December 4, 2023, with oppositions due by December 18, 2023. Additionally, December 4 is the deadline for all necessary pretrial filings. At present, the XRP price has shown a modest reaction to Ripple’s victory, rising 3% since the announcement.
Hot Take: Ripple’s Legal Victory Puts Pressure on SEC
Ripple Labs’ recent legal victory in its ongoing battle against the SEC puts added pressure on the regulator. With the dismissal of the SEC’s appeal motion and a scheduled trial date in April 2024, Ripple has gained momentum in its fight against allegations of selling unregistered securities. The ruling also strengthens Ripple’s position by making an appeal more challenging for the SEC to win. As this high-profile case continues to unfold, the outcome will have significant implications for the cryptocurrency industry and regulatory clarity surrounding digital assets.
By
By
By
