Stock Trader Keith Gill Faces Securities Fraud Allegations
In June 2024, stock trader Keith Gill, known as “Roaring Kitty” from the 2021 GameStop craze, is under fire for alleged securities fraud. A class-action lawsuit filed in the Eastern District of New York accuses Gill of orchestrating a “pump and dump” scheme through his social media posts related to GameStop stock, causing significant price fluctuations between May and June 2024.
Allegations of Stock Price Manipulation Against “Roaring Kitty”
The lawsuit asserts that Keith Gill utilized his social media presence to manipulate the price of GameStop stock for his personal benefit. The complaint claims that Gill initiated buying GameStop call options on E*Trade at low prices on May 12, 2024. The following day, by posting on X after a three-year hiatus, he sparked interest in GameStop, leading to a surge in the stock’s value.
- Gill’s Initial purchases of GameStop call options at low prices
- Boosting GameStop stock value by posting on X for the first time in three years
Subsequently, on June 2, 2024, Keith Gill disclosed his GameStop securities holdings, including 120,000 call options and 5 million shares, via Reddit. This disclosure caused GameStop’s stock price to skyrocket, closing above $45 that day. By June 13, 2024, Gill announced that he had exercised all 120,000 call options, generating profits that he used to acquire an additional 4 million shares in GameStop.
- Keith Gill’s disclosure of his GameStop holdings on Reddit
- Resulting surge in GameStop stock price
Plaintiff Martin Radev alleges that he suffered financial losses due to Keith Gill’s supposed manipulation. Radev claims to have purchased GameStop shares and call options in mid-May, influenced by Gill’s social media activity. The lawsuit accuses Gill of failing to reveal his intentions to sell his options, misleading investors, and causing financial harm.
Lack of Merit in the Legal Claims
Despite the allegations, not all legal experts find merit in the lawsuit. Former federal prosecutor Eric Rosen argued in a blog post on June 30 that the class-action lawsuit lacks a solid legal foundation. Rosen suggested that Gill could easily dismiss the case with a well-structured legal motion.
Rosen’s opinion on the legal challenges of the lawsuit
Rosen contended that expecting Gill to disclose his plans to sell options is unreasonable, as it goes beyond what a typical investor would anticipate. He emphasized that social media posts from a meme stock figure like Roaring Kitty should not dictate investment decisions for informed investors.
- Rosen’s argument on reasonable investor expectations
- Emphasis on the influence of social media posts on investment decisions
Furthermore, Rosen pointed out that proving securities fraud requires demonstrating intentional deception by the accused through the omission of critical information. He noted that random social media memes by Roaring Kitty do not inherently constitute actionable claims that can be proven or disproven.
Hot Take: The Legal Battle Ahead
The legal drama surrounding Keith Gill, also known as “Roaring Kitty,” and the allegations of securities fraud is set to intensify. With contrasting opinions on the merit of the class-action lawsuit, the case could have lasting implications for the intersection of social media influence and financial markets.
By
By
