SEC Takes Action Against FTX Auditor
The United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has filed a lawsuit against Prager Metis, the accounting firm hired by bankrupt crypto exchange FTX, alleging that the firm violated auditor independence rules. The SEC claims that Prager Metis provided auditing services to clients while also offering accounting services, which is prohibited under the auditor independence framework.
Violation of Independence Rules
The SEC’s complaint states that Prager Metis added indemnification provisions improperly in engagement letters for over 200 audits, reviews, and exams from December 2017 to December 2020. This resulted in a lack of independence from clients for those engagements. The firm is also accused of signing accounting reports as independent when they were not.
Failure to Disclose Violations
The SEC also alleges that Prager Metis failed to inform its clients about these violations, despite being informed by the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) that the indemnification provisions breached the independence requirements of federal securities laws. Senators Elizabeth Warren and Ron Wyden have criticized Prager Metis for its lack of independence when auditing cryptocurrency companies.
FTX’s Involvement
Although the SEC’s statement does not mention FTX or any other specific client, it states that there were hundreds of alleged violations throughout the three-year period. FTX had engaged Prager Metis in 2021 before declaring bankruptcy in 2022. Concerns have been raised about the material presented in FTX’s audit, and FTX’s former CEO Sam Bankman-Fried had previously publicly announced positive audit results. The law firm Fenwick & West has also been implicated in the collapse of FTX.
Hot Take: Auditor Independence is Crucial for Investor Protection
Auditor independence is vital for maintaining the integrity of financial reporting and fostering public trust. The SEC’s action against Prager Metis highlights the importance of keeping accounting and auditing tasks separate to avoid potential conflicts of interest. Violations of independence rules can compromise investor protection. The case involving FTX raises concerns about the quality and accuracy of audits conducted in the crypto industry. It serves as a reminder that auditors must uphold their independence and act in the best interests of investors.
By
By
By
By