The Major Issue with Spot Bitcoin ETFs
Daniel Roberts, the co-CEO of Bitcoin mining company Iris Energy, has raised a concern regarding Spot Bitcoin ETFs. He believes that the limited supply of Bitcoin could become a major problem as these funds gain more interest from investors. The total supply of Bitcoin is capped at 21 million BTC, and once this limit is reached, no more can be mined. Roberts is worried about what would happen if these ETFs buy up 30% of the available Bitcoin or if holders refuse to sell. The issuer would need more Bitcoin to create additional shares in the ETF, but if there are no more available, it could lead to complications.
Responses to the Concerns
Some users on X have tried to alleviate Roberts’ concerns by pointing out that if there is a scarcity of Bitcoin, its price will increase until trades begin to clear. This would incentivize some holders to sell their Bitcoin and make profits from their investments. However, the issue still remains that if there is not enough Bitcoin available for the ETFs to acquire, it could create challenges in the long run.
Performance of Spot ETFs on Day 1
Bloomberg analyst James Seyffart provided insights into how Spot Bitcoin ETFs performed on their first day of trading. These funds recorded over $4.6 billion in trading volume, with Grayscale’s GBTC accounting for half of it. BlackRock and Fidelity followed behind with trading volumes of just over $1 billion and $712 million respectively. It is speculated that a significant portion of GBTC’s trading volume might have been outflows rather than inflows as investors may have offloaded their GBTC shares for Spot Bitcoin ETFs with lower fees.
The ProShares Bitcoin Strategy (BITO) ETF also had a busy day, breaking its all-time volume record with $2 billion traded. It is suggested that some of the trades may have been due to redemptions, with investors moving their funds from BTC futures ETFs to Spot Bitcoin ETFs. This aligns with previous predictions by analysts that institutional investors would rotate some of their funds into the Spot ETFs.
Hot Take: The Potential Challenges of Limited Supply
The limited supply of Bitcoin poses a potential challenge for Spot Bitcoin ETFs. As these funds gain popularity and acquire more Bitcoin, there is a risk of running out of available supply. This could lead to complications in creating additional shares for the ETFs, potentially hindering their long-term growth. While some argue that a scarcity of Bitcoin would drive up its price and incentivize holders to sell, it is essential to consider the potential implications of reaching the maximum total supply of 21 million BTC. Finding a balance between demand and supply will be crucial for the success and sustainability of Spot Bitcoin ETFs.